Brief reflections on judgments in the process of Peruvian labor reform

Keywords: labor court judgment, New Labor Procedural Act, argumentation, justification

Abstract

Topics of legal argumentation in labor judgments, under Act No. 29497, New Labor Procedural Act, contain some questions and reflections of some aspects that, in our opinion, have not been addressed with the necessary seriousness and relevance, such as labor court judgments, specifically, in the precision and accurateness degrees that involve its argumentation, since the judgment contains certain guidelines which differentiate it from sentences issued within the framework of other judicial proceedings, such as criminal, civil, family proceedings, etc. In this sense, this article provides some constructive criticism and attempted elements of judgment, in order to novate it in the circuit of issuing of sentences in said Act, emphasizing on argumentation.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

References

Atienza, M. (2016). Las razones del derecho. Teorías de la argumentación jurídica. Palestra Editores.

Castillo, J. L., Luján, M. y Zavaleta, R. (2006). Razonamiento judicial: interpretación, argumentación y motivación de las resoluciones judiciales. ARA Editores.

Congreso de la República (2010). Ley n.° 29497, Nueva Ley Procesal del Trabajo. Lima: 13 de enero de 2010. https://www.pj.gob.pe/wps/wcm/connect/bf9d4d0043eacd588837db829214
c4f0/C.+LEGISLACION+-+Ley+N%C2%BA+29497+Nueva+Ley+Procesal+del+Trabajo.pdf?MOD=AJPERES

Consejo Ejecutivo del Poder Judicial (2014). Resolución Administrativa n.° 002-2014-CE-PJ. Lima: 7 de enero de 2014. https://busquedas.elperuano.pe/normaslegales/circular-referida-a-la-regulacion-del-reenvio-en-los-organos-res-adm-n-002-2014-ce-pj-1055282-1/

Consejo Nacional de la Magistratura (2014). Resolución n.° 120-2014- PCNM. Lima: 28 de mayo de 2014. https://img.lpderecho.pe/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/Precedente-motivación-120-2014-pcnm-caso-Villasis-LP.pdf

Ferrer, J. (2011). Apuntes sobre el concepto de motivación de las decisiones judiciales. Isonomía, (34), 87-107. https://www.scielo.org.mx/pdf/is/n34/n34a4.pdf

Ghirardi, O. A. (1997). El razonamiento judicial. Academia de la Magistratura del Perú.

Published
2022-12-29
How to Cite
Laiza Espinoza, G. L. (2022). Brief reflections on judgments in the process of Peruvian labor reform. The Review of Procedural Labor Law, 5(6), 181-200. https://doi.org/10.47308/rdpt.v5i6.587
Section
Research Articles